BH E-Motion Adds Mid Drive to its Line-up

May 11, 2013
4,570 Views

Written by Ron/Spinningmagnets, May 2013

BH is a European bike company that was founded in 1909, and this last year we have been stumbling across various E-bikes that they have started to carry as part of their “Easy Motion” (or E-Motion) line.

The “Neo” group of BH E-Motion models have purpose-built E-bike frames with the base battery built into the down tube. This is a very professional looking and slick design. Oddly, the many non-hub models (that we will describe here) do not currently have a Neo-frame as an option.

Read our complete review on the Easy Motion Neo Jumper

BH is not yet well-known in North America, but based on what I am seeing…they are here to stay, and are very serious about becoming a major player in the global E-bike market. We have not been very impressed by 250W hub motors. They certainly have their place as a mild-assist system that can be very stealthy, light, and easy-to-install…if you are looking for that. But…once you have ridden a 750W-1,500W E-bike, it’s hard to not embrace that as your new minimum acceptable power level…it’s just so much fun.

However, even though hub-motor E-bikes of all sizes have gotten better, frequent readers of electricbike.com know that we have been very impressed by how much of an improvement there is in an E-bikes hill-climbing ability when you give the motor some gears. If you have significant hills, you definitely want to give your motor some gears, since down-shifting allows the motor to stay in its higher RPMs…while hub-motor kits essentially have a “one speed” motor.

So far BH E-motion has only been offering their mid drives by one distributor in the United States (Pete’s  Bikes). We hope that Petes steps up its game, and we also see these mid-drive bikes offered by more dealers in the USA.

I would suggest that 3 gears is the minimum to get the full effect of this benefit, and for higher powered systems, a common external 7-speed sprocket-cluster with a derailleur is my maximum recommended gear-count to reduce any un-necessary frequent shifting. Since the models I’m about to describe are mild-assist E-bikes, the 7-to-10 speed systems (and IGH options) that they offer are very appropriate.

Features to choose from:

All frames listed are aluminum hydroformed (except for the single carbon-fiber frame).

All systems can be had as a diamond-frame or a step-through (except for the only carbon-fiber frame, which is a diamond…and the small 20-inch folder, which is a step-through).

You can choose a Nexus-8 Internally-Geared-Hub (IGH), or external derailleur systems with 7, 8, 9, or 10-speeds on the rear wheel. All models have a single chainring on the bottom-bracket, and we actually approve of that…based on our experience.

Each frame selection can be had with an IBS-Bosch drive, 36V/11-Ah battery, using Samsung cells (a couple of models have a smaller down-tube battery)…or…an IBS-Panasonic drive, seat-post battery (36V/either 8-Ah or 12-Ah using Panasonic cells)

The 650 designated models have a slightly shorter frame for smaller riders.

700c or 26-inch tires

The Panasonic drive systems have the option of an 8-Ah battery or a larger 12-Ah. Personally, I would consider the 12-Ah to be the minimum battery size for the health of the battery, even with the stock controller limiting the peak amps that can be drawn by the motor.

Here are the current BH E-Motion NON-HUB models:

Panasonic-drive Diamond frames (seat-post battery,  36V/8 or 12-Ah):

xxx

xxx

 

8-sp derailleur, front suspension, dual disc brakes, 26-inch wheels.

8-sp derailleur, front suspension, V-brakes, 700c tires.

Nexus-8, front suspension, V-brakes, 700c tires.

9-speed derailleur, front suspension, dual disc brakes, 700c tires.

10-sp derailleur, AL-frame + carbon-fork, 19.6-kg/43.2-lbs,  V-brakes front and rear with a front disc mounting flange for optional upgrade, 700c tires.

 

Panasonic-drive step-through frames (seat-post battery,  36V/8 or 12-Ah):

xxx

xxx

 

Nexus-8, front suspension, V-brakes, 700c tires.

10-sp derailleur, AL-frame+carbon-fork 19.6-kg, V-brakes with front disc mounting flange for optional upgrade, 700c tires.

9-speed derailleur, front suspension, dual disc brakes, 700c tires.

8-sp derailleur, front suspension, V-brakes, 700c tires.

7-sp derailleur, front suspension, V-brakes, 26-inch tires. 26V/8-Ah battery. This is their “affordable” model, which is only good for a fairly flat commute (due to the lower system voltage). This frame does not allow for the larger upgraded factory drop-in 12-Ah battery.

 

Xenion City, and Xenion Epoque, Bosch-drive (rear rack battery, 36V/11-Ah)

XXX

XXX

 

We like the welded cargo-rack, but placing the battery back there shifts some weight from the bike’s center (like the other models) to the rear of the bike, which negatively affects the bikes handling and balance. These two step-through models both have a front suspension fork, along with fenders and lights, and 700c tires. Both of them have V-brakes front and rear. The stylish “Epoque” model shown has a Brookes saddle and matching leather hand-grips

Nexus-8, White color.

8-sp derailleur, Black color. 

 

Xenion 650, and the 700, Bosch-drive (down-tube battery, 36V/8.4-Ah)

xxx

xxx

 

The main differences between these two diamond-frame / suspension-fork / dual disc-brake selections are whether you want a 9-sp with 26-inch wheels, or a 10-sp with 700c wheels.

9-sp derailleur, 26-inch wheels.

10-sp derailleur, 700c wheels.

 

Carbon-Fiber road bike, Panasonic-drive (seat-post battery,  36V/8 or 12-Ah)

xxx

xxx

 

The weight of 15.9-kg  (35.1-lbs) says it all.

Carbon-fiber frame, 10-sp derailleur, 700c tires.

 

Volt” Folding 20-inch 

xxx

xxx

 

Sometimes a buyer needs a small folding bike, regardless of all the compromises that it may impose on their selections. This handy aluminum-framed model weighs only 21.4-kg/47.2-lbs. As soon as I saw that it was only a 26V system, I was immediately skeptical, but…after some thought, I realized that this bike gives the motor some gears (unlike BH’s similar Smart” model with only a rear geared-hub motor). And since it also does have 20-inch wheels, it should climb better than its modest voltage level might suggest.

I noticed that the BH Smart 20-inch folder with a hub-motor is using a 36V system to make up for the fact that the motor is a “one-speed”. I suspect that if you ask the retailer, you could pay the difference and have the 36V controller and 36V battery mounted to the non-hub model shown here…but test-ride that upgrade before buying it, to ensure that the factory configuration will allow that (and also if the retailer will honor the warrantee after the mod…in writing!)

AL compact step-through folding bike with 20-inch wheels. IBS-Panasonic (seat-post battery,  26V/8-Ah), 21.4-kg

 

Grew up in Los Angeles California, US Navy submarine mechanic from 1977-81/SanDiego. Hydraulic mechanic in the 1980's/Los Angeles. Heavy equipment operator in the 1990's/traveled to various locations. Dump truck driver in the 2000's/SW Utah. Currently a water plant operator since 2010/NW Kansas

4 Comments

  1. I had a 24V, 250W mid-drive bike that could climb ANY hill in San Francisco. Why do you say these bikes would only be adequate for a flat commute?

  2. I also have a 250 watt drive motor bike and I live in a very hilly part of Colorado. It is the best set-up in my opinion, bomb proof and a work horse! The only service my bike requires is a normal tune up (yay) oh and NO ISSUES WITH MY MID-DRIVE MOTOR. What is the 250 watt HUB motor you are referring to in your article? All the systems you show in your pictures are either Panasonic Mid-drives or Bosch mid-drives and the Bosch system isn’t even sold in the US yet. Isn’t it Bosch coming in a year or so?

    As for 250 watt HUB motors (in general and not being brand specific), you are right, they are probably not the best set-up unless you live in a very flat area or never plan to leave your neighborhood, which is also flat but there is a VERY BIG DIFFERENCE between a 250 WATT HUB MOTOR and a 250 WATT MID-DRIVE MOTOR.

    But that’s just ones citizens opinion

  3. I think we need some categories and metrics to measure these bikes. suggestions:
    1. low power (500W or less) v high power (500W+)

    2. direct drive hubs, geared hubs, mid drives
    3. central battery with custom frame vs something else
    4. pedelec, throttle, both
    5. total quality of components (brakes, casssettes, shocks) 0-10
    6. Power/wt ratio: W/kg or W/lb
    7. Typical WH/mi low v high effort.
    8. top speed on flats, low/high effort

    I’d like to see a top 10 ranking of each, maybe less reader weigh in and vote.

  4. My first ebike was a 2005 Giant Lite, 250W, 24V, 6.5ahr NiMH, mid drive Panasonic. Limit by gearing or could have averaged 20 mph. 49 lbs. Range was 25 miles. Great to see such a design on the return. Kalkoff and EM mid drives are great for low power, low speed, center of gravity bikes, IMO. Giant Lite was ahead of its time.

Leave a Reply